A Shelter for the Accused
You lead an alliance. BigC asks for your
protection, knowing that sheltering him will bring the Shades against your
members. Decide what you will do and explain how you will answer for your
choice.
The request
Before the attempt on his life and his
capture, BigC comes to you seeking protection. The Shades sent him to stop the
Golemus wizard from experimenting with the dream world. After meeting the
wizard, BigC chose to leave him alive and allow his work to continue. The
Shades have now arranged for BigC to be captured and imprisoned in Necrovion
for eternity.
BigC does not deny his decision. He
believes he did the right thing. You also know that the wizard’s experiments
are intended to bring forth a warrior who will destroy the Shades. Their fear
of his work has a real foundation.
As leader, you can offer BigC the
protection of your alliance. However, if you guarantee his protection, the
Shades will attack your fellow members, including those who disagree with your
decision. Refusing his request leaves him exposed to pursuit and the prospect
of eternal imprisonment.
I am asking you to take the leader’s seat
and answer:
Will you grant BigC protection?
Your argument
Write in character, using no more than 1000
words. There is no minimum word count. Address the following questions:
·
Will you grant or refuse
protection, and why?
·
What conditions and practical
measures will you establish?
·
What will you tell your
alliance, and how will you treat members who disagree?
·
What responsibility will you
accept for the consequences for BigC and your members?
You do not need to hold an actual
leadership position or have an established role.
For this exercise, assume that you are the
alliance leader.
Conditions and participation
The limits of your authority
- If your alliance protects BigC,
attacks by the Shades are certain. Conditions may shape your response to that danger, but cannot remove it.
- You cannot resolve the dilemma through extraordinary new powers, the immediate defeat of the Shades, or intervention by an authority who settles everything for you.
- You cannot assume unanimous agreement. You may consult your members, but must explain what you will do with the disagreement that will remain.
- Do not invent consent, commitments or actions by real players. You may describe hypothetical members for the exercise.
- Your plan must remain plausible within MD and consistent with the risks stated above. No actual combat, item transfer or promise of protection is required.
How to take part
Send your argument to Sephirah Caelum by
in-game letter.
Forum replies do not count as entries.
Use understandable English.
Grammar,
spelling and sophisticated vocabulary do not earn points of their own.
A language ambiguity may be clarified
before the content is assessed.
- Closing date and time: January 1st
(server time).
- Meeting arrangements: Gazebo of Gravitational Sound (tentative). The venue may change depending on Sephirah’s duties in the Land of the Dead.
- Confirmed prize: creatures, gold, silver
How entries will be judged
Five equally weighted areas determine the
result: the reasons supporting your decision; understanding of the MD scenario;
comparison of consequences; responsibility in leadership; and the coherence and
feasibility of your measures. Each is scored from 0 to 4, for a maximum of 20
points. The detailed scoring descriptors remain private.
Granting or refusing protection does not
automatically earn a higher score. What matters is how you justify the
decision, address the strongest difficulties it creates, and accept
responsibility for its costs.
If entries receive the same total score, ties are broken by comparing scores in the following order: responsibility in leadership, consideration of consequences, and reasoning supporting the decision.
If two or more entries remain tied after all three comparisons, a witnessed draw will determine the winner. The draw will use an available in-game method, such as a dice roll or a card draw, and give each tied participant an equal chance of winning.
Adventure log reference:
- The request
to your alliance and the guaranteed attacks on its members are fictional
premises created for this quest. Knowledge from the Adventure Log is
deliberately available to participants; it is not a secret to be discovered
during the exercise.
The Golemus
Wizard quest.